The Curious Case of Mr. Tipple

Held within the College’s archive collection are a variety of patient case documents, ranging from the common to the peculiar. Practitioners often documented their cases for future reference or publication purposes.

One such publication within the archives that is particularly interesting is “An Account of a Case of Recovery: After the shaft of a chaise had been forced through the thorax”.

tipple case

Front cover of Dr.Maiden’s publication.

This book gives an account of a Mr. Tipple, who in 1812 was in a life-threatening accident where a metal shaft perforated his thorax and pinned him to the wall of a building. What makes this case more fascinating is the fact that he survived the accident! Flicking through the book the reader can find the account of the accident, Dr. Maiden’s examination notes, and the results of the post-mortem taken upon Mr. Tipple’s death in 1822.

The first statement within this book is that of Mr.Tipple, who gives an account of the events that led to his injury. He was arriving at the house of his friend at which point the horse pulling his cart became irritable. Trying to calm the horse, Mr. Tipple began to dissemble the cart:

“ I incautiously took off the bridle, as the first step towards disengaging the horse from the chaise and harness: the horse immediately became unruly…the horse made a violent plunge, and thrust me, by the end of the off shaft, against the part of the chaise-house which projects from the clump of out-buildings…at this instant, I felt the end of the shaft perforate my side, under my left arm…and I soon felt the end of the shaft pass from under my right arm, occasioning acute pain…” [1]

tipple illustration

Interpretation of how the shaft penetrated Mr. Tipple’s chest.

The shaft of the chaise had passed all the way through Mr. Tipple’s chest, exiting at about the level of his right arm pit. Witness accounts of the accident state that he was slightly suspended off the ground by the shaft, standing on his toes to relieve some of the pressure in his chest.

tipple case 6

Illustration showing the site of the accident. A) The position of the horse and chaise. B) The situation of Mr. Tipple. C) The end of the shaft penetrating into the chaise house.

Once the shaft was removed, Mr. Tipple entered the house and retired to the guest bedroom, where he removed his shirt and lay back slightly on the bed. It was at this point that he experienced periods of dyspnoea (difficulty breathing) and began to feel faint. The doctor arrived 10 minutes after the accident occurred, and on examining the wounds found there to be an escape of air-filled blood.

In attempt to relieve his difficulty in breathing, doctors frequently drained blood from his body and did so by opening a vein in his right arm. This procedure gave Mr. Tipple immediate rest and his breathing would return to normal. (At this time in history, bloodletting was the go to procedure for a variety of ailments, but in this case it was done to reduce internal haemorrhaging in the chest. The practice of draining the chest via a chest tube was not made popular until the 1950s, which could be why Dr. Maiden let blood from the arm instead).

chaise illustration

Illustration showing the portion of the chaise that pierced Mr. Tipple’s side.

For weeks the situation was the same; Mr. Tipple would experience bouts of dyspnoea and his blood would be drained to relieve the pressure. This continued for the rest of his life, along with periods of cardiac arrhythmia, which ended 10 years after the accident, in 1823.

On examination of the body during the post-mortem, it was visible that the shaft had entered the thoracic cavity between the second and third ribs through the second intercostal space, and exiting on the right hand side via the second intercostal space. The holes in the intercostal muscles created by the shaft had been closed over by a clear membranous tissue to which the lungs adhered. This was most likely scar tissue. The lungs themselves were intact and had not been punctured by the shaft because of its blunt end. The blunt end would not have been sharp enough to actually damage the lung tissue, which would have simply been pushed out of the way. Mr. Tipple’s heart was also untouched by the shaft; however there was some hypertrophy in the region of the right ventricle. This would suggest that Mr.Tipple’s death was a result of heart failure caused by a fibrosis of the lungs. This fibrosis (scarring and stiffening) of the lungs would have been a result of trauma from the accident ten years before. The breathlessness that he experienced after the accident was due to a pneumothorax induced by the sucking chest wound from the shaft penetration.

A curious case indeed, it is a mystery how Mr. Tipple not only survived the trauma, but also the volume of blood that was drained from his body during treatment. Although such an accident could easily recur, (maybe not in the exact same circumstances), healthcare today is much more advanced and more than capable to properly diagnose and treat such cases.

For more details about Mr. Tipple’s case and the above document, feel free to contact us at: library@rcpsg.ac.uk

Many thanks to doctors-in-training, Jenny Crabbe and Rosie Jacks, for their expertise and guidance on this patient case.

 

References

  1. Maiden, W., 1824. An Account of a Case of Recovery after the Shaft of a Chaise had been Forced through the Thorax: to which is now added a statement of the health of the sufferer from the period of his recovery until his decease: with the appearances of injured parts after death. Carpenter&Son: London.

 

Old and new surgical tools

Our Digitisation Project Intern expands on the previous post about Dr Harry Lillie’s medical bag.

The recent donation of a medical bag belonging to Dr Harry R.Lillie, a medical officer aboard whaling ships during World War Two, revealed some interesting stories. It also highlighted fascinating insights in the development of basic surgical instruments.

hr-kit-3

Dr Lillie’s surgical kit

Within the bag, one item drew much attention- a set of surgical tools (above). These tools drew attention not because of their scarcity, or obscurity, but because of their profound similarities to modern tools used today.

hr-kit-7

1939 or 2016?

A set of modern dissection tools was located and compared with the surgical tools found in Lillie’s surgical case. The designs of the tools are very similar, as are their materials. Modern dissection tools are made of stainless steel, as are Lillie’s. Most surgical instrument makers adopted stainless steel since its popularity grew in the 1930s. Even the canvas bags are remarkably similar.

kirstys-tools

2016 or 1939?

Apart from some signs of wear and tear, it is hard to believe these two surgical kits have over 75 years between them.

 

Foundations of the College Library

On 29th October 1732, a fire broke out in a house in Glasgow, next door to the home of one John Colquhoun, Clerk of the Faculty of Physicians and Surgeons of Glasgow. The fire spread quickly to Colquhoun’s house and many of Colquhoun’s possessions were burnt to a crisp. Also in Colquhoun’s possession at this time, and thus sadly lost to the fire, was the Faculty’s second minute book, covering the period 1688 to 1732. This leaves us today with a frustrating gap in the early records of the Faculty.

The lack of reliable records for the years between 1688 and 1733 makes it especially difficult to piece together the early history of the Faculty Library. The Library was founded in 1698, shortly after the first Faculty Hall was erected near the Trongate. We know, largely thanks to the efforts of the 19th century librarian Alexander Duncan, that the nucleus of the library was formed by donations from Faculty members and their well-to-do patients and friends. In Duncan’s book, Memorials of the Faculty (1896), he transcribes a manuscript listing “the names of such worthie persons as have gifted books to the Chierurgions Librarie in Glasgow”. Although Duncan notes that “many of [the books] are still on the shelves,” he does not provide a list of their titles, so it is difficult to know what the size and scope of the Library was like in its early years.

This is where our ongoing ESTC matching project comes in. As part of our work to match our current holdings to the records on the English Short Title Catalogue, library staff and volunteers have been closely scrutinising many of the pre-1800 titles in our collections. In the last month we have started looking at books from the Lister Room, and have rediscovered some important inscriptions indicating early donations to and purchases by the Faculty Library.

IMG_0165

The title page of Robert Bayfield’s “Exercitationes anatomicæ in varias regiones humani corporis”, with the autograph of Dr Peter Patoun.

In one diminutive volume, containing the first and second editions of Robert Bayfield’s Exercitationes anatomicae in varias regiones humani corporis (ESTC R31574 and R23670, respectively), we find an “Ex Libris” inscription dated 1687, belonging to Dr Peter Patoun. Dr Patoun (sometimes spelled “Patoune” or “Paton”) was a Glaswegian physician who graduated with an M.D. from Leiden in 1691 and became, according to Duncan, “one of the leading physicians in Glasgow”. He was Praeses (i.e. President) of the Faculty between 1709 and 1710, and is known to have donated a number of books to both the Faculty Library and the Library of the University of Glasgow. Although this is the first of his books we have identified here, a list of his donations to the university appears in volume 3 of Munimenta Alme Universitatis Glasguensis (1854, p.440).

Not all the donations to the library were from Faculty members. Our copy of the 7th edition of Philip Barrough’s The method of physick (ESTC S101230) features this fairly detailed inscription: “This book is gifted by the Lady Barrowfield Elder to the Chyrs of Glasgow – the Library, by the influence of Mr Henry Marshall … Bibliothecarius, Nov. 26 1705”. Both Lady Barrowfield and Mr Henry Marshall appear in the list of “worthie persons” to have donated books to the library, the latter listed as “Mr. Henrie Marshall, Chyrurgeon Apothecar”. According to the list, Marshall also persuaded the Earl of Wigton to donate some books, although we have yet to identify these.

These donations formed the nucleus of the library, and eventually the Faculty began buying books to further expand the collection. On the front flyleaf of Plantarum historiae universalis Oxoniensis pars tertia (ESTC R8391), we find this inscription, “Ex Libris Facultatis Chirurgorum Glasguensium, Londin: Empt. 1707”, marking out the 3rd volume of Robert Morison’s herbal as one of the earliest purchases for the Faculty Library. We’ve only just started matching Lister Room items to ESTC, so we are keeping our fingers crossed that more evidence about the Library’s early life is waiting to be uncovered.

#ColorOurCollections

1st-5th February 2016

Join us and a host of other cultural institutions around the world as we invite you to #ColorOurCollections!

We’ve selected images from Peter Lowe’s (founder of our College in 1599) book, The Whole Course of Chirurgerie. Originally published in 1597, this book was the very first general surgical text to be published in English. The text takes the form of a dialogue between a teacher (John Cointret) and his pupil (Peter Lowe) and covers five different classes of operation.

Download an illustration, get creative with those colouring pens and share your masterpieces with us on twitter (@RCPSGlibrary) using the hashtag #ColorOurCollections.

Instruments for a little caseLowe002

Lowe003 Lowe004

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Lowe006Lowe005

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

And thanks to The New York Academy of Medicine (@NYAMHistory) for coming up with this brilliant idea!

Great Expectations

Friday, 15 May 2015.

After the success of last year’s event we’re very excited to once again be taking part in Festival of Museums. The festival runs from the 15th-17th May 2015 with lots of museums and heritage sites across Scotland taking part. You can find out more at http://www.festivalofmuseums.com

Our event takes place on the 15th May when we’ll be hosting a special evening celebrating the fascinating history of midwifery. In celebration of 100 years of the Midwife (Scotland) Act, Joan Cameron, who is Senior Lecturer in the Mother and Infant Research Unit at the University of Dundee, will be delivering a lecture discussing the contribution of midwifery to the care of women and babies. The evening will also showcase some amazing items from our collection including the beautifully illustrated Gravid Uterus by Scottish anatomist and surgeon William Hunter (1718-1783), the ground-breaking works of obstetrician William Smellie (1697-1763) and a selection of early midwifery instruments.

Refreshments will be available from 6.15pm with the chance to view our special midwifery exhibition. The lecture begins at 7pm.

Places are limited, so please book early to avoid disappointment.

Contact library@rcpsg.ac.uk or call 0141 221 6072.

Poster advertising great expectations

Guest blog: Work Experience in the College Library

This year’s placement from the University of Strathclyde Information and Library Studies MSc/PgDip course was Angela McLean.  Angela has kindly agreed to share her experience of working in the Library here as follows:

“The MSc Information and Library Studies course offered at the University of Strathclyde, allows students the opportunity to experience five weeks of work in a library setting. I couldn’t believe it when I was told that the library I had specifically asked for had been given to me and that I would be working at the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons.

My first task during my placement was to take an inventory of a selection of the rare books that were believed to be duplicates, this was a great opportunity to spend all day with rare books and, more practically, to gain a better insight into the library collection available at the College.

After I had finished this process, I was never short of tasks to do and helped with the archives, as well as researching and photographing more rare books from the collection for the ‘Adopt-a-book’ scheme.

Books waiting to be adopted and conserved.

Books waiting to be adopted and conserved.

I was also in charge of the library for a few hours on my own, which thankfully went by without a hitch and I learned how to fix the indispensable coffee machine available in the library (trust me when I say it is a vital component of the library).

The Library tea and coffee machine - learning how to operate this is an essential skill.

The Library tea and coffee machine – learning how to operate this is an essential skill.

My time at the Royal College has made me certain that I definitely want to pursue a career in libraries because of the sheer variety of tasks that need done on a daily basis. Also, I felt very welcomed by all the library staff and wider College staff which made it a delight to turn up every day.  In fact, I enjoyed my five weeks working in the Library that I have decided to stay on and help with a few odd jobs.”

Please do get in touch with the library should you wish to adopt a book by emailing library@rcpsg.ac.uk

Dental instruments of the late 18th/early 19th centuries

This is the second blog about some of the dentistry items we have in the historical collections at the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Glasgow.  The first blog, published in November 2013 was on the topic of Renaissance Dentistry.

Today I will be exploring some of the implements used for tooth extraction in the 18th and 19th centuries. One of our main sources for this is Savigny’s catalogue of instruments published in 1798. This work, entitled A Collection of Engravings Representing the most modern and approved instruments used in the practice of surgery is the first illustrated British catalogue of surgical instruments.  In his introduction, Savigny laments that in nearly twenty years as a workman there were not engravings and explanations of such items, particularly in consequence of the “rapid and astonishing improvements” of recent years.  He notes the publication of two others on the Continent, namely Brambilla at Vienna and Peret at Paris.  The book consists of engraved plates of instruments, largely reproduced in life size along with an accompanying text describing the items. The work provides a wealth of information about the surgical instruments in use during this period.

During the late 18th century/early 19th century the most frequently used instrument for extraction was the toothkey.

Forceps and scaling instruments from Savigny's catalogue, 1798

Forceps and scaling instruments from Savigny’s catalogue, 1798

Several forms of toothkey are illustrated on the right hand side of Plate XIV (above). The third item down on the right hand side is an older version of the toothkey with a straight stem and bolster.  The instrument in this form was first  mentioned in 1742.  Above it is an example of an improved instrument which came into use by 1770 with a curve at its extremity to aid extraction.   Savigny himself invented a modification to the key and this is illustrated on the bottom right of the plate. He writes “on comparing and reflecting on the various forms which the key instrument has received, I have ever found their principal defect to arise from the depth of the bolster, which, even in the smallest, describes in its action so large a circle as to occasion unavoidable inconvenience; and in the larger, or deeper ones, certain danger of fracturing the alveolar process, and of being followed by consequences always painful and frequently dangerous”.  Savigny’s design of bolster was intended to raise the offending tooth in a nearly perpendicular direction and thus lessen the chances of bruising or laceration.

An instrument known as a Spring or German key is  illustrated at the top left hand side of Plate XIV while below it is what Savigny terms a “Pulican” (Pelican) used for the extraction of the incisors.  The two instruments on the bottom left hand side are punches used for extracting stumps.  Above them is an instrument used for extracting the incisors of children by raising them perpendicularly.

Plate XIV from Savigny's Catalogue, 1798

Plate XIV from Savigny’s Catalogue, 1798

Plate XV illustrates instruments for scaling and cleaning the teeth (left hand side), two levers for forcing out stumps (top right hand side), various forceps or paces used for extracting the stump or removing the tooth after it had been disengaged from its socket by the toothkey.  The forceps at the bottom of the plate, termed Front or Hawk’s-bill Paces, was used in a similar way to the pelican to extract the incisors.  A set of gum lancets is illustrated on the bottom left hand side of the plate.  These were used to detach the gum from the tooth before extraction.

If you are interested in viewing Savigny’s catalogue or any of the items mentioned in our blog posts then please get in contact with the library to arrange an appointment email: library@rcpsg.ac.uk